HR Candle
List Your Store

Candle Stores & Studios in Port Jefferson, NY

Whether you're after soy candles, custom scents, or a candle making workshop, these 2 candle stores serve Port Jefferson, NY — check hours and call ahead for classes. Providers listed in Port Jefferson cover candle making studios & classes and candle stores. Port Jefferson sits in Suffolk County, New York. Other New York cities covered include New York, Buffalo and Poughkeepsie.

Ask local candle stores about classes, custom orders & events

Ask about candle making classes, custom orders, or private events at Port Jefferson candle stores and studios.

1. Birch & Main Candle Making Studios & Classes

230 E Main St
📞 6318862053 🌐 Website 📍 View on Google Maps

2. Willow + Harlow Candle Company and Studio Candle Stores

208 E Main St
📞 +16312605473 🌐 Website 📍 View on Google Maps

Candle shops in Port Jefferson, NY: a local guide

We currently track 2 candle shops and makers serving Port Jefferson, NY in Suffolk County.

What candles costs in Port Jefferson

Handmade candles in Port Jefferson usually run $15-$40 depending on size, wax, and scent; soy and beeswax cost more than paraffin but burn cleaner and longer. Larger jars and gift sets run higher.

What to look for in a candle shop in Port Jefferson

  • For gifts, ask about gift sets, custom scents, and local pickup near Port Jefferson.
  • Read reviews for scent throw and consistency — weak scent or tunneling are the usual complaints.
  • Look for soy, coconut, or beeswax wax if you want a cleaner, longer burn than paraffin.
  • Check that scents use quality fragrance or essential oils and aren't overpowering unlit.
  • Support local Port Jefferson makers — small-batch candles are often better poured and better value than mass brands.

Questions to ask before you buy

  • Can I pick up locally in Port Jefferson?
  • What's your policy if the scent isn't right?
  • What wax and wick do you use, and how long does it burn?
  • Are the fragrances phthalate-free or made with essential oils?
  • Do you make candles in-house or resell?

Many Port Jefferson listings also carry soy, beeswax, and scented candles, gifts, and candle-making supplies.

Frequently asked questions

How much do handmade candles cost in Port Jefferson?

Handmade candles from Port Jefferson shops usually run $15 to $40 depending on size, wax, and scent. Soy and beeswax cost more than paraffin but burn cleaner and longer.

What is the best type of candle wax?

Soy, coconut, and beeswax burn cleaner and longer than paraffin and hold scent well. Many Port Jefferson makers use them, so ask what a shop pours.

Why is my candle tunneling or burning too fast?

It is usually a wick or wax-pool issue. Trim the wick to about a quarter inch and let the first burn melt the top edge to edge. A good shop can recommend the right size.

Do Port Jefferson candle shops make custom scents or gift sets?

Many small makers offer custom scents, gift sets, and local pickup. Ask the shops above, as it is a common request for weddings and events.

Own a candle store or studio in Port Jefferson?

Get featured at the top of this page → Claim your listing, add photos, and appear above the competition.